Cookout Milkshakes
The legendary Cook Out shake board: more than 40 commonly reported flavors, how to order and customize your shake, and honest notes on price and nutrition.
The Flavor Board
Below are flavors commonly reported by fans — grouped for browsing, not ranked. This list is not exhaustive, and the lineup varies by location and season. Your restaurant’s board is the final word on what’s pouring today.
Candy & Cookie
Images are illustrative.
Oreo
A fan staple
$3.59–$3.99
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut butter + chocolate
$3.59–$3.99
Snickers
Chocolate, caramel, and peanut notes
$3.59–$3.99
Heath Toffee
Buttery toffee crunch
$3.59–$3.99
Mint Oreo
Mint + cookie
$3.59–$3.99
Fruit
Banana
Classic fruit pick
$3.59–$3.99
Strawberry
A fan favorite
$3.59–$3.99
Peach
A Southern favorite
$3.59–$3.99
Pineapple
Tropical option
$3.59–$3.99
Mango
Tropical option
$3.59–$3.99
Blueberry
Berry pick
$3.59–$3.99
Cherry
Berry pick
$3.59–$3.99
Watermelon
Often seasonal
$3.59–$3.99
Banana Berry
Combo flavor
$3.59–$3.99
Banana Pineapple
Combo flavor
$3.59–$3.99
Classic
Chocolate
The timeless pick
$3.59–$3.99
Vanilla
The timeless pick
$3.59–$3.99
Chocolate Malt
Malted richness
$3.59–$3.99
Vanilla Malt
Malted richness
$3.59–$3.99
Double Chocolate
Extra chocolate intensity
$3.59–$3.99
Chocolate Cherry
Chocolate + cherry
$3.59–$3.99
Coffee & More
Mocha
Coffee + chocolate
$3.59–$3.99
Cappuccino
Coffee pick
$3.59–$3.99
Coffee
Coffee pick
$3.59–$3.99
Caramel Fudge
Caramel richness
$3.59–$3.99
Peanut Butter
Nutty pick
$3.59–$3.99
Peanut Butter Banana
Combo flavor
$3.59–$3.99
Coconut
Tropical pick
$3.59–$3.99
Cheerwine
Cherry-soda-inspired; regional
$3.59–$3.99
Eggnog
Seasonal, typically around the holidays
$3.59–$3.99
Lemon
Citrus pick
$3.59–$3.99
Lime
Citrus pick
$3.59–$3.99
Orange
Citrus pick
$3.59–$3.99
Sizes
Cook Out shakes are generally served in a single generous size — fans describe them as thick, made-to-order, and filling enough to count as dessert on their own. Specific size options and ounces are not published centrally, so if your location offers more than one size, the board or the staff can confirm.
How to Order & Customize
- Order it solo — a shake on its own is the classic Cook Out dessert run.
- Swap it into a tray — many locations let you replace the tray’s drink with a milkshake for an upcharge. Ask at the window; the upcharge varies by location.
- Mix flavors — fans love combining flavors (banana + peanut butter, anyone). Not every location will do it, so ask politely.
- Time it right — shakes are made to order, so they can add a few minutes to your wait during a rush.
Cookout Milkshakes Price Snapshot
Figures below are commonly reported ranges from independent third-party menu sites checked in October 2026 — Cook Out publishes no official prices, and actual prices vary by location.
Commonly reported price range
| Item | Commonly reported price range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Any milkshake, all 40+ flavors | $3.59 – $3.99 | Sources disagree — reports vary |
| Milkshake as tray drink upgrade | $1.50 – $2.00 | Commonly reported range |
For the full picture and our methodology, see the
Cookout menu pricesguide.
See the full prices guide For the final word, check Cook Out’s official site.
Calorie Snapshot
Cook Out does not publish calorie counts centrally, so there is no official figure for its milkshakes — any number you see online is unverified. For what is (and isn’t) known about the menu, see our nutrition and calorie guide.
Reported calories by flavor
Figures below are third-party reported ranges collected from independent menu sites in October 2026 — Cook Out publishes no official nutrition data, and actual counts vary by location, preparation, and portion.
Reported calories
| Item | Reported calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Banana | 538 | |
| Banana Berry | 671 | |
| Banana Pineapple | 566 | |
| Blueberry | 617 | |
| Cappuccino | 555 | |
| Caramel Fudge | 677 | |
| Cheerwine | Not consistently reported | |
| Cherry | 600 | Name mapping approximate |
| Chocolate | 620–651 | Reports vary |
| Chocolate Cherry | 665 | |
| Chocolate Malt | 671 | Single source |
| Coconut | Not consistently reported | |
| Coffee | Not consistently reported | |
| Double Chocolate | Not consistently reported | |
| Eggnog | Not consistently reported | |
| Heath Toffee | Not consistently reported | |
| Lemon | Not consistently reported | |
| Lime | Not consistently reported | |
| Mango | Not consistently reported | |
| Mint Oreo | 853 | |
| Mocha | Not consistently reported | |
| Orange | Not consistently reported | |
| Oreo | 802 | |
| Peach | 547 | |
| Peanut Butter | 847 | |
| Peanut Butter Banana | 864 | |
| Pineapple | 575 | |
| Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup | 894 | Single source |
| Snickers | 720 | |
| Strawberry | 610 | |
| Vanilla | 555 | |
| Vanilla Malt | Not consistently reported | |
| Watermelon | 530 | Single source |
Twelve flavors have no consistently reported figure — those are listed as such rather than guessed. Figures are per regular shake.
For every category and our full methodology, see the nutrition and calorie guide.